HUF -  Deduction from HUF Business Income

HUF being a separate assessable entity as per the provisions of Section 2(31) of the Income-tax Act,1961 and a separate legal entity as well is very well capable of doing business in its own name. There is no bar on HUF doing business. The business in such a case can be either carried on in the name of the HUF or if it is required to give a separate name to the business, then in such cases, the HUF can become proprietor of such a business and business name can be distinctive and different from the name of the HUF. Whenever HUF does any business, it would have to obtain Trade Licence, Profession Tax Registration etc which are generally required to be obtained as per the Rules and Regulations prevailing in the State in which the business is being carried on.

The HUF while doing business can claim all the deductions which are available for being claimed under the heading Income from business and profession under Chapter IV-D of the Income-tax Act, 1961 which contains Sections 28 to Section 44DB of the Act except the Sections as follows:

1. Deduction u/s 33AC relating to Reserves for shipping business is available only to a company.

2. Deduction u/s 34A relating to uñabsorbed depreciation and unabsorbed investment allowance for limited period in case of certain domestic companies.

3. Deduction u/s 35DD relating to Amortization of expenditure in case of amalgamation or demerger.

There are some other provisions also contained in Chapter IV-D of the Income-tax Act, 1961, deductions in respect of which is not available to a HUF mainly because of the nature of expenses which can only arise in case of assessees other than HUFs. For further details, it is better to refer to Chapter IV-D of the Income-tax Act, 1961 as above. Normally all expenses which are incurred for purposes of business can be claimed. Tax is on net income and on real income. Section 37 is residuary section to take care of all unspecified expenses. Deduction for depreciation, rent, interest, salary etc. are admissible.

Some of the issues arising out of the Computation of Income under the head Profits/gains of Business/Profession are dealt with herein below:


1. Whether remuneration/salary paid to Karta/other members of the HUF is deductible from the Business income of HUF?

The Karta of the family generally manages the affairs of the family including the business run by the family. The other family members may also be engaged in assisting the Karta or may be independently/actively engaged in the running of the family business. A question arises whether during the course of their engagement, can Karta and/or other members of the family draw remuneration/salary from the business and if so whether the same would be deductible from the business income. The aforesaid issue was subject matter of appeal before the Apex Court in the case of Jugal Kishore Baldeo Sahai vs CIT. (1967) EL SCR 4161= (1967) 63 ITR 2381 and the Apex COurt after detailed reasoning allowed the appeal by holding the remuneration paid to Karta to be deductible u/s 10(2) (xv) of the 1922 Act by holding as follows in Para 8

In our view, if a remuneration is paid to the karta of the family under a valid agreement which is bonafide and in the interest of, and expedient for, the business of the family and the payment is genuine and not excessive, such remuneration must be held to be an expenditure laid out wholly at exclusively for the purpose of the business of the family and must be aif owed as an expenditure under Section 10(2) (xv) of the.Act.

The Apex Court relied on its earlier case of Jitmal Bhuraa1 vs CIT reported in (1962) 44 ITR 887 wherein it was held that a Hindu Undivided family can be allowed to deduct salary paid to a member of the family, if the payment is made as a matter of commercial or business expediency and the services are rendered to the fanfily. In the case of Jitmal Bhuramal though the Hon’ble Court held that the deduction on account of salary could only be made while computing the profits of the partnership to which the junior members of HUF were rendering the service and not in the assessment of the HUF.


Thus, it can be concluded that the salary/remuneration drawn by the Karta/members of HUF are deductible as a business expenditure provided the payment is genuine and reasonable.


2. Whether interest on loan taken from coparcener is deductible out of income of HUF

The Apex Court in
the ese of CIT vs Gopal Bansilal Inani (2000) 245 ITR 2 in a very short judgement held that such interest is not deductible. However, it must be noted that this decision has to be understood in the facts of the case, which are available in CIT vs Venugopal Inani [19991 239 ITR 514 (SC), which was followed in this case. It was not a case of complete partition by metes and bounds recognised under section 171, so that separate accounts as between the HUF and coparceners though acceptable in general law could not be accepted, because of the deeming provision under section 171 requiring the assessment to be continued to be made in the hands of the HUF in the absence of an order recognising the partition under section 171. The decision as such has to be read in a limited context and cannot be applied in general.


3. Withdrawal of Development rebate in case of partial partition of HUF.

An interesting question arose in the case of CIT vs S.Balasubramnian (1998) 3 SCC 596 [= (1998) 230 fiR 934] where the Assessee was a HUF and had claimed certain development rebate on new plant and machinery installed for the purposes of business of the Joint family. Thereafter the said plant and machinery was allotted on partial partition to the coparceners and the coparceners sold the said plant and machinery within a period of 8 years and the question arose whether in such cases there was a transfer of plant and machinery, so as to warrant withdrawal of the development rebate allowed to the HUF asséssee. The Hon’ble Apex Court held as follows:


i )         In so far as the transfer of assets on partial partition is concerned, the same cannot be said to be a transfer within the meaning of Section 2(47) of Income-tax Act,1961 on account of the fact that the essence of joint Hindu family property is unity of ownership and community of interest. Shares df members are not defined. However, in view of the unity of ownership and community of. interest of all coparceners in the joint Hindu family business, the position on partition of joint Hindu family business, whether it ‘be partial or complete is very similar in law to the position on dissolution of partnership firm. On partition the shares of thecoparceners in the joint family business become defined and their community of interest is separated. Division of assets is a matter of mutual adjustment of accounts as in the case of a dissolved partnership firm. The property which so comes to the share of the coparceners, therefore, cannot be considered as transfer by the joint family to a coparcener or the extinguishment of the right of the joint family in that property, the joint family not having its own separate interest in that property which can be transferred.


ii)         Thereafter, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that though in the present case, it cannot be said that the HUf had transferred the assets within a period of eight years, however in the present case, the coparceners had sold the assets to third party within the period of 8 years and therefore this wa a case where the assessee had not used the machinery for his business for a period of eight years even if the assessee is taken as a compendium. of joint hindu family-cum-coparceners and thereafter it held that the development rebate was rightly withdrawn.


HUF -  Capital Gain Account
HUF -  Deduction from HUF Business Income
Income Derived From Funds Of HUF -Whether Individual Income Or Family Income
Gift by HUF to its Member
Gift To Minor Daughters Out Of HUF Property Prior To Marriage
Gift of HUF Property to Stranger or to any Person who is a Alien to HUF
Clubbing Provisions In Case Of Gifts Received By HUF
Applicability of Clubbing Provisions in case Karta of a HUF is a Partner in a Firm
Gifts received by HUF from Aliens / Strangers
HUF - Investment Options
Concept of Multiple HUF’s
Whether a Single Member can Constitute a HUF ?
Whether any Limit is placed on Number of Members of a HUF ?
Whether HUF- Can Be Constituted with only Female Members ?
Drawings / Expenses of HUF
Whether HUF can be a Shareholder / Subscriber to the MOA ( Memorandum Of Association)  of a Company
Whether HUF can be a Member of a Cooperative Society ?
Whether HUF can be a Partner ?
Can KARTA of a HUF enter into Partnership with another Member of HUF ?
Can There Be A Partnership Between Two HUFs?
Effect Of Death Of Karta In Case Of Partnership Firm
Whether HUF Can Be A Proprietor ?
Whether HUF Can Be A Trustee / Settler ?
HUF - Aliyasantana Law
HUF - Marumakkattayam Law
Power of KARTA in relation to HUF
Managing Members in relation to HUF
Whether a Female can become a Karta ?
Tax Planning TIPS for HUF
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “Ancestral”
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “Stridhan”
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “Mitakshara”
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “ Dayabhaga”
Meaning of the term ‘Coparcener’ of HUF
Power of ‘Coparcener’ of HUF
Difference between a ‘Coparcener’ and a ‘Member’
Whether Husband / Wife Can Constitute A HUF ?
‘Maintenance of Accounts’ by HUF
‘Audit of Accounts’ by HUF
Applicability Of The ‘Accounting Standards’ On HUF
Whether Merger Of Two HUF is Possible ?
Residential Status of the HUF under I.T. Act.1956
‘Coparcener Property’ under HUF
Tally.ERP9 Book Online Order Tally.ERP9 Book Content
Tax Management
Computation of Gross Total Income
FAQ on Taxation System
CORPORATE TAX (Taxation in Companies)
Amendment of Sections at a Glance for Assessment Year 2019-2020 under Income Tax Act.
GST (Goods & Service Tax ) Taxation System In India
HUF (Hindu Undivided Family) Taxation System, Tax Planning & Tax Saving
Tax Guide for NRI - Tax Planning, Tax Saving, Investment Guidance for Non-Resident Indians !
Tax Management - Managerial & Financial Decisions
Business Tax Procedure & Management
LIBRARY @ Tax Management
TAX & INVESTMENT GUIDE FOR "NRI"- Non-Resident Indians !
PRESCRIBED FORMS WITH with Section / Rules
Tax Tutorials
E-Payment Of Direct Taxes
Filing Of Return Of Income
Interest for Delay in Filing the Return of Income [Section 234 A]
Interest for default in Payment of Advance Tax [Section 234B]
Provisions Of 'Income-Tax Law' Useful For Non-Residents
MAT (Minimum Alternate Tax)
AMT ( Alternative Minimum Tax)
Tax On Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)
Tax On Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG)
Exemption[ Section-54] For Capital Gains Arising On Transfer Of Residential House Property
Tax Treatment Of Gifts Received By An Individual Or HUF
Set Off And Carry Forward Of Loss Under The Income-Tax Act
Interest For Delay In Payment of TDS/TCS And For Non-Payment Of Tax Demanded
Tax Deduction/Collection Account Number (TAN)
How to apply for PAN ?
Refund Of Excess Tax Paid By The Taxpayer (Sections - 237 to 245 )
Presumptive Taxation Scheme of Section 44AD
Presumptive Taxation Scheme of Section 44ADA
Presumptive Taxation Scheme of Section 44AE
Deduction in respect of Life Insurance Premium, PPF, NSC, etc. [Section 80C]
Deduction in respect of Medical Insurance Premium [Section 80D]
Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) from Interest, other than Interest on Securities (Section-194A)
Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) from Interest on Securities (Section 193)
Late Filing Fees And Penalty For Failure To Furnish/Delay In Furnishing The TDS/TCS Statements

Most Popular Links :

Clubing of Income Deduction U/s 80C
Allowances Us-17(3) Exemption-Salary
Tax Amendment-2015 Taxable Income
Clubing of Income Tax Deductions
HUF Deduction HUF Investment
Gift by HUF HUF Tax Planning Tips
Tax Saving Schemes Tax Planning Tips
Refund of Tax Fringe Benefit Tax-FBT
Return Filing Assessment / Scrutiny
Notice from I.T. Dept. Incomes Types @ TDS
Exemptions-Tax Returns “Summon” U/s 131
'Black Money' @ I.Tax Big Gifts To Be Taxed
'Appeals' under I.Tax Assessment @ I.Tax
Exempted Incomes Capital Gain
Business & Professions House Property
Salaries @ I.Tax Partnership Firm
'Penalty' under I.Tax Act. Tax Ready Reckoner
Charitable Trust Useful Links @ I.Tax

All efforts are made to keep the content of this site correct and up-to-date. But, this site does not make any claim regarding the information provided on its pages as correct and up-to-date. The contents of this site cannot be treated or interpreted as a statement of law. In case, any loss or damage is caused to any person due to his/her treating or interpreting the contents of this site or any part thereof as correct, complete and up-to-date statement of law out of ignorance or otherwise, this site will not be liable in any manner whatsoever for such loss or damage.

The visitors may click here to visit the web site of Income Tax Department for resolving their doubts or for clarifications

Tally.ERP9 Book Online Order Tally.ERP9 Book Content