Bigger HUF And Smaller HUF

 

Often it is seen that the term Bigger HUF and Smaller HUF is used in the matters relating to Joint family Property and a question arises as to what is Bigger HUF and what is Smaller HUF. Bigger HUF generally refers to the HUF consisting of all the members of Joint Hindu Family and the Smaller HUF refers to a branch of the such family which is carved out of the bigger HUF and which holds property which is ancestral in the hands of that branch only and which is separately identifiable to that branch and the members of that branch only. In the case of CIT vs M.M.Khanna(1963) 49 ITR 232 (Bom), the Hon’ble Bombay High Court held that a joint Hindu family springs from a Hindu male and every Hindu male can be the stock of a fresh descent constituting a joint Hindu family or a Hindu coparcenary. Where, from a Hindu male a joint Hindu family springs into existence, this family goes on having its different branches and sub- branches. Each branch starts with the male descendant of the common ancestor and each sub-branch with the male descendant of the head of the branch. While the entire group proceeding from the common ancestor with its several branches and sub-branches in the normal undivided state is a Hindu joint family, each of the branchesand each of the sub-branches again is a Hindu joint family according to the concept of a joint family under the Hindu law. It is, therefore, possible for a main Hindu undivided family to be composed of a large number of branch families, each of the branches itself being a Hindu joint family and so also the sub-branches of those branches. Where a Hindu joint family consists of branch families each of the branch families may possess property which constitutes the joint family property of that branch alone and in which the other branches or the main Hindu family as such have no right or interest. The smaller joint family can have a legal existence and is capable of holding property of its own as distinct from the property of the main family while the main family remains intact. While the main family may possess property which belongs to the entire family or in other words belongs to the hotchpotch of the main family, each of the smaller joint families existing within the main family may possess property which belongs to its own hotchpotch.

Under the Hindu law any member of a joint family can throw his self- acquired property in the hotchpotch of the family to which he belongs and thus make it the joint family property of the said family. A member of the smaller joint family can, therefore, impress his self-acquired property with the character of the joint family property of the smaller family to which he belongs. He is no doubt also a member of the main joint family and he can, if he so chooses, throw his self-acquired property in the hotchpotch of the main family also. But that will be a matter of his volition. There is nothing in the Hindu law or in the concept of a joint family under the Hindu law which prevents him from throwing his property in the hotchpotch of the smaller unit to which he belongs, while the larger unit remains intact.

The throwing of property into the common hotchpotch of the joint family is possible even if the family hotchpotch is empty, i.e., even if there is no nucleus of the family. In this regard, reference can be had to the following decisions:

  1. Subramania Iyer (R.) vs Commissioner of Income-tax (1955) 28 hR 352(Mad).

  2. Commissioner of Income-tax vs Talukdar (P.N.)(1982) 135 ITR 628(Cal)
Thus, the Bigger HUF and the Smaller HUF can simultaneously function without any hindrance and simultaneously be assessed to the Income-tax.

MORE TOPICS ....

HUF -  Capital Gain Account
HUF -  Deduction from HUF Business Income
Income Derived From Funds Of HUF -Whether Individual Income Or Family Income
Gift by HUF to its Member
Gift To Minor Daughters Out Of HUF Property Prior To Marriage
Gift of HUF Property to Stranger or to any Person who is a Alien to HUF
Clubbing Provisions In Case Of Gifts Received By HUF
Applicability of Clubbing Provisions in case Karta of a HUF is a Partner in a Firm
Gifts received by HUF from Aliens / Strangers
HUF - Investment Options
Concept of Multiple HUF’s
Whether a Single Member can Constitute a HUF ?
Whether any Limit is placed on Number of Members of a HUF ?
Whether HUF- Can Be Constituted with only Female Members ?
Drawings / Expenses of HUF
Whether HUF can be a Shareholder / Subscriber to the MOA ( Memorandum Of Association)  of a Company
Whether HUF can be a Member of a Cooperative Society ?
Whether HUF can be a Partner ?
Can KARTA of a HUF enter into Partnership with another Member of HUF ?
Can There Be A Partnership Between Two HUFs?
Effect Of Death Of Karta In Case Of Partnership Firm
Whether HUF Can Be A Proprietor ?
Whether HUF Can Be A Trustee / Settler ?
HUF - Aliyasantana Law
HUF - Marumakkattayam Law
Power of KARTA in relation to HUF
Managing Members in relation to HUF
Whether a Female can become a Karta ?
Tax Planning TIPS for HUF
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “Ancestral”
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “Stridhan”
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “Mitakshara”
HUF - Meaning Of Important Term- “ Dayabhaga”
Meaning of the term ‘Coparcener’ of HUF
Power of ‘Coparcener’ of HUF
Difference between a ‘Coparcener’ and a ‘Member’
Whether Husband / Wife Can Constitute A HUF ?
HUF - RECOVERY PROVISIONS
‘Maintenance of Accounts’ by HUF
‘Audit of Accounts’ by HUF
Applicability Of The ‘Accounting Standards’ On HUF
Whether Merger Of Two HUF is Possible ?
Residential Status of the HUF under I.T. Act.1956
‘Coparcener Property’ under HUF
 
Get Updated ...
Tally.ERP 9 Book
 
Guide & FAQ on Tax Knowledgebase @ Taxation Income Tax @ Glance HUF - Formation, Planning & Taxation
Charitable & Religious TRUST NRI (Tax Planning,Saving,Investemnt) Budget 2017-2018 GST (FAQ, Law, Act. Rules, Schedule, Enrollment)
________________________________________________________________________________________

Disclaimer:
All efforts are made to keep the content of this site correct and up-to-date. But, this site does not make any claim regarding the information provided on its pages as correct and up-to-date. The contents of this site cannot be treated or interpreted as a statement of law. In case, any loss or damage is caused to any person due to his/her treating or interpreting the contents of this site or any part thereof as correct, complete and up-to-date statement of law out of ignorance or otherwise, this site will not be liable in any manner whatsoever for such loss or damage.

The visitors may click here to visit the web site of Income Tax Department for resolving their doubts or for clarifications